CertainTeed’s Landmark series is a popular choice among residential homeowners due to its high-quality materials and heavier weight. These shingles are known for their durability, appearance, performance, and cost. The company offers a range of roofing shingles, including 3-tab, architectural, and multilayered architectural asphalt shingles. The Landmark PRO roofing shingles are designed to appear fuller and more dimensional than the flattish 3-tab shingle.
Although there are some differences between these high-quality CertainTeed shingles, they are considered some of the heaviest and most durable feeling shingles we tested. The Landmark Pro shingles are thicker and heavier with superior adhesive compared to regular landmark shingles. However, they are more expensive and not as reliable as the basic Landmark shingles.
CertainTeed’s Landmark asphalt shingle line is a high-quality, reliable choice and affordable option. They offer thicker layers and superior quality, making them a popular choice for homeowners looking for a long-lasting and resilient roofing system. Shingle warranties are worthless, as they only cover manufacturing defects, not shingle wear out.
In summary, CertainTeed’s Landmark series is a popular choice for homeowners due to their durability, appearance, performance, and cost. The company’s Landmark shingles are known for their affordability, durability, and style, making them a reliable choice for protecting homes.
📹 Consumer Reports: The best asphalt shingles for your roof
Are Landmark shingles class 3?
CertainTeed Landmark Shingle Colors are class 3 impact resistant roofing shingles available in various colors for various exterior finishes. These shingles are known for their weight, thickness, durability, and beauty, ensuring long-lasting roof installation. CertainTeed SureStart PLUS Enhanced Warranties, only available from certified roofing companies, extend the non-pro-rated portion of the warranty on CertainTeed Integrity Roof Systems and add other benefits. Elite Roofers, a SELECT ShingleMaster™ company, can offer roof replacement with the best CertainTeed warranties, including up to 25 years of workmanship coverage.
Does shingle brand matter?
The brand of shingle used during roof replacement impacts cost, material warranty, and color/design options. Major shingle manufacturers offer three types of asphalt shingles (3-tab, architectural, and luxury), with some offering more options like Certainteed’s luxury shingles or Owens Corning’s one. They also offer different material warranties and functions specific to their brand, but most are similar but called something different.
Is CertainTeed Landmark a class 4 shingle?
CertainTeed shingles are made from materials with the highest impact resistance rating, Class 4, which is achieved through testing with steel balls simulating 90-mph hailstones. These shingles are designed to protect against extreme weather elements, including updrafts, crosswinds, and gusty weather. The unrelenting protection of CertainTeed shingles is verified by Underwriter’s Laboratory through their Class 4 UL 2218 Impact Test. With their extensive selection of products, homeowners can transform any ordinary space into something extraordinary.
What brand of shingle is best?
Forbes Home analyzed 10 major roofing shingle companies and 80 products to determine the best roofing shingles. The company’s star rating is determined by evaluating various metrics, including company information, customer reviews, BBB grade, accreditation, and the ratio of complaints to reviews. The overall ranking is based on the number of years a company has been in business, customer reviews from sites like Trustpilot, Consumer Affairs, Google Maps, ReviewMeta, and Fakespot, and the overall rating.
Is CertainTeed landmark a Class 4 shingle?
CertainTeed shingles are made from materials with the highest impact resistance rating, Class 4, which is achieved through testing with steel balls simulating 90-mph hailstones. These shingles are designed to protect against extreme weather elements, including updrafts, crosswinds, and gusty weather. The unrelenting protection of CertainTeed shingles is verified by Underwriter’s Laboratory through their Class 4 UL 2218 Impact Test. With their extensive selection of products, homeowners can transform any ordinary space into something extraordinary.
Are there different quality shingles?
Asphalt fibreglass laminated shingles are categorized into three main types: entry-level, medium grade, and designer or premium grade. As the grade increases, so does the amount of asphalt and shingle life expectancy. The quality of a shingle is determined by the weight needed to roof a 10x10x10 area, or 100 square feet.
Are Landmark shingles good quality?
Landmark shingles, despite their high cost, offer long-term benefits due to their durability and attractive appearance. CertainTeed’s strong warranty ensures a cost-effective choice over time. A CertainTeed Select Contractor ensures installation meets high standards, providing peace of mind and protection for years to come. Knowing these costs helps plan and budget for roof replacement, ensuring the best value for your investment. To find a CertainTeed Select Contractor in your area, visit the CertainTeed website and enter your zip code to find a list of contractors nearby.
What is the CertainTeed landmark shingles problem?
Roofs have a limited lifespan, typically ranging from 20 to 50 years, depending on the material and climate conditions. If your roof is approaching or exceeding its expected lifespan, it’s time to consider a replacement. Regular inspections for visible damage, such as missing, cracked, or curling shingles, can compromise the roof’s integrity and lead to leaks. Water leaks on ceilings or walls indicate roof leaks, which can result from damaged or deteriorating shingles.
Excessive granule loss in gutters or downspouts indicates deteriorating shingles and may need replacement. Mold or algae growth on your roof can affect its appearance and lead to structural issues, making it essential to address and consider a roof replacement if needed. CertainTeed, a trusted roofing manufacturer, has a reputation for excellence in the building materials industry, having been in business since 1904. Their commitment to quality and longevity make them a top choice for roofing needs.
How can I tell if my shingles are Class 4?
Underwriters Laboratories have established standards and tests for the impact resistance of asphalt shingles, ranging from Class 1 to 4, with Class 4 shingles having the highest resistance. The impact rating is usually marked on the cellophane on the underside of the shingle. An older method was to attach a layer of reinforcing fabric called scrim to the back of the shingle. Other methods include increasing the weight of the mat used, making the shingle thicker by increasing the thickness of the asphalt layer, or modifying the asphalt mix by adding polymers. These polymers can improve the physical characteristics of various materials, including shingle strength and impact resistance in asphalt shingles.
Is CertainTeed better than GAF?
Certainteed shingles are viewed as higher quality by many roofers, despite some comparing GAF shingles to cheap ones. While GAF is lower-cost, Certainteed offers a wider variety of colors and is preferred for its aesthetic appeal.
What class rating is Landmark shingles?
CertainTeed’s Landmark asphalt shingles offer performance perks such as meeting industry UL manufacturing quality standards, dual-layered construction for extra protection, and Class A fire-resistance rating. They come with CertainTeed’s lifetime-limited warranty and other warranties to back up their performance.
📹 Roof Shingle Olympics – Expert Ranks 12 Shingle Brands From Worst To Best | Reliance Roof Troop
Need a new roof? Watch this revealing video before choosing shingles! Local roofer Daniel Wagenmaker tested 12 top-selling …
We’re about to re-roof and had been favoring GAF UHDZ because of how hot it is in SC and potential for hurricanes (3 since 2016, so the GAF unlimited wind warranty was seductive). Our original roof was OC (Berkshire series which is no longer available) and, based on your testing, I think I’ll now have estimates resubmitted with the OC Duration.
Thank you for this review/data – this definitely deserves more views. Oddly enough, my first, lowest priced, and best-put-together quote (from a well-rated roofer) offers Malarkey Vista (and Highlander). I think that makes it a pretty easy call – easy enough that I may just cancel my other appointments for quotes.
I’m not a roofer, but can see how these qualities in a roof can help you decide, ive seen cheap roofs lose 75% of their granules. Malarkey does feel a bit sponsored here I have to say. All in all many roofers use Owens duration and it has a 50 year warranty so I think that vs the price is pretty good. Cool roofs and title 24 requirements, plus newer technology is helping a ton to keep shingle life much past 30 years. I have 2 cheap shingled roofs 25 years old..no leaks, tons of granular loss and a sloppy install. Roasted by cali heat rain and wind. Do your homework people and good luck!
Thank you for your analysis and ratings. I am about to have a couple of roofs replaced so this comes in handy. I would say about your granule loss test is that you should have a consistent,unbiased way of applying the pressure to the shingles and not sure that you did (the article shows someone hand holding the tool).
Outstanding information brother! we are considering the malarky Vista..the one area I wish malarky improved on would be their very limited color choices..while we are thrilled to see vista now rated as class 4, that line has so few color options and the ones it Does have, are not so p(leasing to the eye.. sienna blend for example, with its checkerboard effect and orangey tinge.. I wish malarky just went with even color tones with subtle,instead of crazy daramatic highlights..when trying to choose a color option, I also noticed that malarky’s stock photos of shingle examples on a home would vary wildly fromone pic to another,even though it was supposed to be the same color!… that said, it seems a fantastic shingle. your review came across as having a Slight bias, maybe becuz you work with malarky products? but you aimed to present the facts, kept it fair and let the testing speak for itself as far as performance…This review was every bit as thorough and extensive as Roofing Insights has done on their website…. side note: in our neighborhood, nearly Every home has had their roofs redone from a recent hailstorm and the shingles were a couple of certainteed landmark and the vast majority were GAF timberline hdz… I wished I could see malarky examples to view actual,on house appearances but man, they are rare here!
Excellent! Why? Thorough, quantified, logical. Yes, as one other poster indicated, there may be a slight lack of complete objectivity, (Malarkey always wins), but if that’s the truth, so be it. Wish others followed your model. Thanks for the time you rook to produce it. I will be forwarding it to my friends.
Fantastic! This is the only article anyone needs to see that’s shopping for shingles. You covered everything in great detail. I noticed you didn’t discuss the Scotchgard type products that some are claiming prevent black streaking from algae. Is that just one of the marketing features you mentioned? Thanks again for all the great info
My roofer is installing Certainteed Landmark Pro next spring on my home. It is his preferred shingle to install. Malarkey is not available in my market area. Your article confirms my confidence in the Landmark Pro. My installer hand nails all shingles. He may already do this, but I will request he nails on the lower part of the 1 inch nail zone to ensure each nail is set in the common bond.
It’s funny because in real life situations in the NE I install OC Duration. Since 2011 over 30k squares with zero issues. I came from GAF as a Master Elite with many roof failures and blow offs. OC Duration is far superior than TAMKO, GAF, and CT. Also no streaking with the copper granules. I have installed from NJ to Massachusetts.
I’ve been a Roofer for over 20 years. The Owens corning sure nail strip does not hold up overtime. The fabric itself will peel off the shingle very easily, especially after it goes through the seasonal changes. From hot to cold. This is a issue because the sealant of the top shingle rest on the fabric of the bottom shingle. So you do not get a good bond from shingle to shingle. it would be better without the fabric strip. Then let the shingle bond to the asphalt of the shingle underneath it. There’s also an issue with the hook blades not cutting the fabric smoothly. hook blades are great for cutting asphalt shingles but not much else. This causes a problem when you’re trying to cut shingles to flash around a pipe or a chimney. Because the blade will pull the fabric strip from the shingle instead of cutting it smoothly .After all the issues I’ve seen with Owens Corning I would never recommend them to anybody or put them on my house.
Hands-down, this is the best shingle comparison article I’ve seen on the Internet yet! Fantastic work. Metrics and statistical results from thoughtfully created testing/measurement. You’ve rooted yourself in the truth, not opinions. This’ll shine through to win you business. Keep it up!👍 Do you have it in a written report (results/summary) format for people to download – PDF or written out on your website?
There is something missed in your tests which is important to compare. Algae resistance. How does each of these shingle manuf brands hold up to their claims of algae reistance. Atlas Pinnacle shows a longer resistance than Landmark Pro. Is it true that their Scotchguard is really better? What about the others you tested?
Excellent reviews! But I do not understand how you do not recommend GAF Timberline HDZ when they companites offer incredible 50 year shingle warranty with full replacement and 25 year workmanship with transferrable warranty??? (I had 3 big companies come out and each gave about the exact same pitch and installed only GAF.)
I’ve been in business in Dallas Fort Worth for a little more than 40 years. I find there is still much I don’t know. One thing I’m sure if. Certainteed is head and shoulders THE WORST PRODUCT on market. I’ve had 3 times as many Certainteed shingles I’ve turned in as defective. I have not had them cover one of these in probably 10 years. I normally don’t bring it up to a customer because they will not pay for it.
If you had ever installed and/or repaired these shingles, you might have changed some of your ratings. For example, I’ve seen the sealant separate from OC duration when they get wet. The sealant literally falls off the back of the shingle. I have found that the GAF Timberline HDZ, while having seemingly less sealant, has a better quality sealant. I saw solar panels fly off a roof after hurricane Ian, and not one shingle was missing. 140 mph winds!
Let’s address some things. First, this guy is a roofing contractor that uses almost exclusively Malarkey products. So big shock that he is going to promote Malarkey products. Completely biased opinion. In addition, he is going to pick and choose stats and use specific words to make it seem like Malarkey is the best shingle on the market. And if it just so happens to be that Malarkey outcompetes the competition’s lines of shingles in EVERY single aspect like this man tried to highlight, then why is anyone using other manufacturers. I mean if Malarkey is better at literally every category, why would anyone buy other shingles? Lastly, in the disclaimer he says that he isn’t sponsored by, paid, or endorsed by Malarkey yet I can guarantee they are getting special pricing from their distributor. On their website you can see they CLEARLY favor Malarkey. You can be sure that they have cobranded materials like polos, hoodies, etc.
Of course Malarkey isn’t available in Michigan, nor is Certainteed Landmark Pro but Lowes does have the inferior Landmark. Looks like it’ll be Owens Corning Duration from Menards since at least it has “up to 25-year Algae Resistance Warranty” whatever that’s worth, which is something you guys could’ve tested. Maybe I’ll suggest it to Project Farm. Our TKO shingles were the very worst I’ve ever seen and didn’t bother with the settlement since there’s no way I’d ever trust IKO again.
If I understood correctly, you stated that GAF Timberline HDz shingles are not impact rated, but I just saw that they have a UL2218 Class 4 rating, did this recently change? Is this the rating scale to which you were referring? TY for the article, I know more about shingles than I thought I would ever want to know. LOL
Really needs to have a pricing ranking – skipping that misses a crucial criteria thst makes a big difference when choosing a shingle. Also would have liked full performance metrics on each test (granule loss), pictures on results after impact test, etc. Would have helped with not feeling as much like a sales ad for malarkey
Malarkey polymer modified shingles do not last in Florida. As a 20-year roofer, I have seen how all of these shingles fail over time in New York State, and in Florida. GAF, OC Duration, and IKO Dynasty seem to hold up the best in Florida. Malarkey is the #1 shingle in NYS and its not even close. Certainteed Landmark suffers extreme granule loss after 10 years. Atlas and IKO Cambridge and any Tamko shingles are the worst.